Survey: Who are America’s Greatest Mentors? [2024]

We asked 3,000 Americans to cast their votes for the most cherished leader in the country’s history. From presidents to activists, discover who captured the hearts of the nation and why these figures continue to inspire us today.

Key Findings

1. The Diversity of Mentorship Across Fields

One striking observation from our poll results is the wide range of fields in which these figures left their mark. 

From pioneering educators like Horace Mann to visionary architects like Frank Lloyd Wright, America’s most inspirational mentors weren’t confined to a single profession. 

This demonstrates that mentorship can emerge in many forms – whether through groundbreaking scientific contributions, social activism, or even the arts.

2. The Importance of Overcoming Adversity

Many of the people featured, such as Booker T. Washington and Harriet Tubman, came from backgrounds of extreme hardship. 

Their mentorship was born from their personal resilience and dedication to helping others rise above difficult circumstances.

This suggests that people are drawn to mentors who not only succeed but also show perseverance in the face of adversity.

3. The Role of Regional Legacy

While some mentors are known for their national impact, many are closely associated with specific states or regions.

Figures like Georgia O’Keeffe from New Mexico or Chief Seattle from Washington left lasting legacies that reflect the cultural, historical, and geographical uniqueness of their home states. 

4. Mentorship Through Social Change

Many top figures from the poll, such as Dorothea Dix and Medgar Evers were deeply involved in social justice movements. 

Their influence as mentors was rooted in their activism for human rights and equality. 

This underscores the power of mentorship in not just teaching but also leading by example in the pursuit of a more just society.

5. Women Leading the Way in Mentorship

The list showcases a significant number of women who played powerful mentorship roles in American history, like Jeannette Rankin, the first woman elected to Congress, and Zora Neale Hurston, an influential author and anthropologist. 

Their inclusion is a testament to the evolving recognition of women’s contributions to mentorship, education, and social reform.

6. Cross-Generational Influence

Figures like Thomas Edison and George Washington Carver mentored not only those within their immediate sphere but also future generations. 

Their work laid the foundation for technological advancements, education reform, and scientific progress that continues to inspire people today. 

7. Mentorship in Artistic Expression

Beyond the fields of education and civil rights, the poll also recognizes the importance of mentorship in the arts. 

Georgia O’Keeffe and Sacagawea, for example, influenced generations through their artistic and cultural expressions, reminding us that mentorship isn’t limited to formal settings like schools or businesses.

Instead, it can emerge through storytelling, cultural preservation, and creative pursuits.

8. Forgotten but Not Lost

Some figures, such as Sophie B. Wright and Dorothy Canfield Fisher are lesser known but were instrumental in shaping education and social welfare in their regions. 

9. Founders of Educational Institutions

Several figures from the poll, such as James Madison (Virginia), John Adams (Massachusetts), and John Muir (California), were not only educators but also founders of institutions. 

Their legacy goes beyond their personal mentorship—they laid the groundwork for future generations to learn and grow, setting up entire systems of education and civic responsibility.

10. The Power of Quiet Leaders

Not all mentors from the list were outspoken public figures. Individuals like Laura Ingalls Wilder, known for her literary contributions, mentored through quiet persistence, storytelling, and cultural preservation. 

Her work as a mentor continues to resonate with those who value the power of everyday leadership and influence.

By Irene Chan
Irene Chan is a writer and marketing project manager who specializes in helping coaches and startup founders simplify the process of creating content. That's why she loves Paperbell, as it simplifies every part of the business!
September 25, 2024

Are You Undercharging?

Find Out In This Free Report

Ever wondered exactly what other coaches are offering, and ​for how much? Find out if you’re charging too much or too ​little by benchmarking your own rates with this free report.

Subscribe to our updates for instant access: