Coaching VS Mentoring: A Guide for Coaches Who Wear Different Hats

coaching vs mentoring

Mentoring and coaching are terms that are thrown around a lot casually. However, they both have their own individual methodology for client work and can be equally powerful — when used in the right setting.

Whether you want to work with clients as a coach vs mentor is not as much a question of your personal style but the approach they can most benefit from. In this article, we’ll lead you through the key differences and misconceptions about being a mentor vs coach and which one might be more impactful for your practice.

What is Mentoring vs Coaching?

Let’s start with the basics. Although sometimes confused with each other, coaching and mentoring are two distinct methodologies.

Coaching is a goal-oriented process that empowers individuals to unlock their potential and achieve specific objectives. As a coach, you help your clients find their own answers and solutions to their challenges and help them grow through these experiences.

On the flip side, mentoring involves a seasoned professional, the mentor, guiding a less-experienced individual, the mentee, based on personal or professional experience. They are typically an expert in the areas they’re advising. 

Both methodologies have their distinct training programs that teach you how to apply them when working with clients. Though formal training or certification isn’t required to become a coach or a mentor, these programs can give you a good foundation and much-needed structure for your client work.

[ Read: What Is a Life Coach & How They Differ From a Therapist or Consultant ]

What Is the Difference Between Coaching and Mentoring?

The crux of the matter lies in the approach. Coaching centers on asking powerful questions, active listening, and facilitating self-discovery. It’s about helping individuals tap into their inner resources to find solutions.

Mentoring, however, leans towards sharing wisdom and experience and providing guidance. The mentor draws from their own journey to give advice to the mentee.

Here’s a summary of how the different aspects of these two methodologies differ.

RelationshipMany mentors have a personal relationship with the mentee based on shared experiences. They act as an experienced and trusted advisor, offering wisdom, guidance, and advice. Coaches maintain a professional relationship with the client and focus on specific goals and development areas.
PurposeMentors primarily focus on personal and professional growth, drawing from their own experiences to help the mentee navigate challenges and make informed decisions. Coaches are goal-oriented and work with clients to identify objectives, create action plans, and develop skills and strategies to achieve those goals.
ExpertiseMentors often possess specific knowledge and experience in the mentee’s field or industry, providing industry-specific insights and guidance. Coaches may not have expertise in the client’s specific field but are skilled in coaching methodologies, asking powerful questions, and facilitating the client’s self-discovery and growth.
StructureMentorship relationships are typically more informal and long-term, allowing for ongoing support and guidance over an extended period. Coaching relationships are more structured and time-bound, focusing on specific objectives or areas of development within a defined timeframe.
ApproachMentors share their own experiences, offer advice, and provide guidance based on their perspectives and expertise.Coaches employ active listening, powerful questioning, and reflective techniques to help clients gain clarity, explore possibilities, and develop their own solutions.
AccountabilityMentors can keep mentees accountable throughout their ongoing mentoring relationship, but it’s typically not their primary focus.Coaches often place a stronger emphasis on accountability. They establish clear action steps, monitor progress, and provide support and feedback to ensure you stay on track with your goals.

Examples of Coaching vs Mentoring a Client

Let’s say a client approaches you with a personal or professional challenge you have experience with. You can coach them through this challenge or advise them as a mentor. Here’s what this would look like.

Examples of a Coaching Approach

  • Asking coaching questions that encourage self-reflection: “What specific outcome are you aiming for in this situation?” or “How do you envision overcoming this challenge?”
  • Setting clear and achievable goals: “What small steps can you take to move closer to your desired outcome?”
  • Giving feedback on patterns: “I’ve noticed a pattern in your approach, let’s explore how we can break this cycle.”
  • Keeping them accountable: “What commitments can you make to yourself to address this challenge, and how can I support you in staying accountable?”

In addition to asking questions, coaches also use active listening to help their clients. Instead of barging in with the solution, you may listen to your client’s thought process and whether an underlying issue or belief is standing in their way.

Examples of a Mentoring Approach

  • Sharing personal examples or stories: “When I faced a similar challenge, here’s what I did…”
  • Giving guidance based on expertise: “In my experience, this is what would make the biggest impact in your case…”
  • Presenting industry insights (in a professional setting): “Here’s what the data shows about this common issue…” or “Let’s look at some best practices and industry trends in your niche…”
  • Utilizing their network: “Would you mind if I introduce you to someone who might have the solution for you? or “This program could be a great opportunity for you to get the resources, knowledge, and connections you need in this matter.”

As a mentor, you might not be able to address your client’s challenges immediately, but you can offer ongoing support and guidance. Through a long-term mentoring relationship, you can see your client progress in their career development and personal growth and advise them at each milestone.

When to Use Coaching

Coaching might be a better approach for your client work when…

  • Your client wants to come up with specific goals, and they seek guidance on achieving these objectives
  • They want to explore their personal strengths, values, and potential blind spots
  • They want to find ways to develop new skills or adopt new patterns of behavior
  • They need to reduce the complexity surrounding their focus area to overcome their challenges
  • They want to improve their self-esteem or make better decisions in a particular area of their life
  • They want to explore different options for their future and choose the one that suits them the most personally
  • They need someone to keep them accountable for their goals and give them structure to stay on track
  • They want to develop new habits and perspectives
  • They want to become better leaders, find their own leadership style, and find more work-life balance
  • They want to work on themselves more holistically or on an area of their life that’s very individual, like their spirituality
  • They need your help to adapt to new circumstances or transition into new situations

When to Use Mentoring

Mentoring might be a better approach for your client work when…

  • Your client wants to advance in their career or grow their business in an industry or field that you’re experienced in
  • They need industry-specific insights, advice, and knowledge that you can give
  • They want to broaden their network and find new opportunities in your field
  • They can benefit from your personal experience and lessons learned
  • They see you as a role model, they look up to you, and they want to emulate your path to success
  • They’re looking for a more long-term relationship that offers them guidance at their various milestones as they progress on their journey
  • They are specifically looking for knowledge transfer so that they can learn from your expertise
  • They need help with complex decision-making in a senior-level role that you’ve fulfilled in the past
  • They want to develop skills that you excel in

Why Are Some People Confused Between Coaching and Mentoring?

The difference between a mentor and a coach can often be blurry because of their overlapping qualities. Both coaching and mentoring involve providing support and guidance, as well as goal-setting. They both aim to help clients grow in their personal lives or careers and overcome challenges, just in different ways.

Another reason these methodologies might be mixed up is that mentoring is sometimes used more casually. People might refer to someone as a mentor sharing advice in an informal, unstructured relationship without accepting payment. This is different from professional mentors, who are often trained in a structured methodology and charge fees for their services.

As you build your online presence and brand, make sure that you highlight which methodologies you’re using in your practice. A discovery session with your potential clients is also a great space to clear any confusion so they know what they can expect from you.

Can You Be Both a Coach and a Mentor?

Yes, many professionals work as both coaches and mentors. They combine both methodologies to provide more effective guidance for their clients. The key is in recognizing the right time and context for using coaching vs mentoring.

Set expectations beforehand on what approach you use in your practice and your distinct qualifications. Then, use your discernment to decide whether to put on your coaching or mentoring hat in a particular session or situation.

If your client needs guidance on a specific skill or situation you’re experienced in, put on your mentoring hat and share some advice. If you focus on empowering your client to find their own solutions and answers, switch to coaching instead.

What Is the Difference Between Coaching vs Mentoring vs Consulting?

Consulting is another service-based profession that gets thrown in the mix a lot, so let’s define how each of these differs.

As we’ve seen before, coaching helps clients identify and achieve personal or professional objectives by guiding them through self-discovery, skill development, and problem-solving.

Mentoring is when a more experienced individual (mentor) advises a less experienced individual (mentee) in a particular field or industry

Now, with consulting, it gets a little tricky. Consulting is also an advisory service with specialized expertise. However, consultants use different frameworks and focus more on analysis to offer solutions.

A mentoring relationship is typically more long-term, personal, and rooted in trust and mutual respect. On the other hand, consultants provide project-based services and focus on achieving specific outcomes in a business setting that are independent of the individual.

What Is the Difference Between an Authoritative Coaching Style vs Mentoring?

If you’ve been reading up on the different styles of coaching, you might be familiar with one that’s called an autocratic coaching style. It’s often used when the goals are clearly defined for the coachee, and there’s not much wiggle room for discovering different options. It focuses a lot on accountability and is especially effective in critical situations requiring urgent decisions.

So, while it could sound like this coaching style is more directive and similar to mentoring, it still follows a coaching methodology. This means that while a mentor would give personal advice in a (usually long-term) client relationship, an autocratic coach would still let the client come to their own conclusions, just with more firm guidance.

Automate Your Coaching and Mentoring Client Management With Paperbell

Wouldn’t it be nice if your client management would neatly run itself in the background while you’re making an impact as a coach or mentor?

That’s the thought that inspired Paperbell, the all-in-one client management software made by coaches for coaches.

Paperbell runs your day-to-day processes, from payments, contract signing, scheduling, and more. It keeps all your client information in one place while conveniently linking your landing page to your client management system.

Try Paperbell now for free with your first client.

coaching vs mentoring

By Annamaria Nagy
Annamaria Nagy is a Brand Identity Coach and Copywriter. She's been writing for over 10 years about topics like personal development, coaching, and business. She was previously the Head of SEO at the leading transformational education company, Mindvalley.
November 29, 2023

Are You Undercharging?

Find Out In This Free Report

Ever wondered exactly what other coaches are offering, and ​for how much? Find out if you’re charging too much or too ​little by benchmarking your own rates with this free report.

Subscribe to our updates for instant access: